The 28 Best Costco Bakery Items, Ranked

Costco's track record when it comes to pie is hit or miss, and this one is a miss. We wish the filling of this pecan pie had a deeper, more molasses-y sweetness. The crust also tends to be too soggy for our liking.

One of Costco's most exciting bakery categories is the mini cake—which is better described as a massive cupcake. We love them for the most part, but this carrot cake is the weakest of the bunch. There's not enough carrot and the spice level could be amped up a few notches.

Fighting for last place in the mini cake category is the snickerdoodle flavor. We love snickerdoodles on their own, and we love cinnamon flavored desserts in general. But something about this mini cake isn't hitting. It's not spiced enough to be a solid fall dessert, in our opinion.

Costco's cookies are in a league of their own. The confetti cookies aren't bad, per se. But they don't blow us away enough to justify buying an entire package.

People go feral for Costco's chocolate peanut butter pie, and we don't blame them. Chocolate and peanut butter is one of the best flavor combinations on Earth. But it's almost so decadent and rich that we can't finish a single slice on our own, let alone the whole pie.

We may be biased as New Yorkers, but the bagels at Costco are just okay. Laura Lamb from @costcohotfinds, however, swears by them. She keeps them in the freezer and uses them all week. They also get bonus points for coming in fun flavors like Parmesan.

If you've ever eaten the Trader Joe's pancake bread, you probably have a good idea of what this butter cinnamon sugar loaf tastes like. It's sugary, soft, and a great stand-in for a basic pound cake. But it's a little too plain to enjoy on its own.

The double chocolate muffin is a year round offering at the Costco bakery, and fans love it. But our critique is like the one we have for the butter cinnamon sugar loaf—it's just a tad too plain for our taste.

Compared to an average supermarket sourdough loaf, Costco has the most flavorful and affordable version. It's pillowy soft in the center and has a mild tartness. Our only gripe is that its storage in a plastic bag decimates any semblance of a crunchy exterior.

Costco uses four different berries in this pie. It strikes the ideal balance of sweet and tart, has a delightfully crispy crust, and is peak summer vibes. But at around $19 per pie, it's a little too pricey to be a regular purchase.

Cornbread has plenty of applications, but our favorite way to eat it is with a cozy bowl of chili. Their specialty cornbread is speckled with smoky (but not spicy!) green chile, which adds a lovely Southwestern twist to a classic treat.

Red velvet is a classic for a reason. And these mini cakes do not disappoint. There's a hearty layer of cream cheese frosting on top of a chocolate-y, super moist cake. If you're a red velvet lover like we are, buy a package.

Costco's pumpkin pie is consistent. If you bring it to a Thanksgiving potluck, it'll get just as much praise as Grandma's recipe. That being said, we wish the warm spices were much more intense.

Costco danishes are the best way to recreate the experience of being in a luxurious coffee shop in your own home. Their cherry-filled danishes are flaky, buttery, and perfectly sweet. Your breakfast routine will never be the same.

This is one of the many seasonal Costco bakery products that deserves to be sold year round. The pumpkin cheesecake is decadent, tangy, and perfectly spiced.

There's no way we can rank Costco baked goods without including the beloved chocolate chunk cookies. They're chewy, filled with chocolate, and have a certain nostalgia that you can't replicate with a homemade cookie.

The classic chocolate chunk is incredible on its own, but add marshmallows and graham crackers and it's on an entirely new level. These s'mores cookies from Costco are a relatively new offering, and we can already see them being a fan favorite.

A lemon meringue pie and a cheesecake walk into a Costco...and magic happens. It's dense, it's fluffy, it's sweet, it's tart, it's everything we want in a summer dessert.